Good morning Ted. Those Caldercraft ropes look pretty decent as far as “kit ropes” go. I don’t have experience with Caldercraft ropes however from the photos there is a big difference from the quality ropes you can buy from ropes of scale or Drydock models. My experience using good quality ropes vs kit ropes :
1. Scale. Most kits do not give sufficient variants for proper scale. If you buy “aftermarket” you have the ability to check the scale and buy any size thread you need
2. Accuracy. Ropes of scale make ropes with the weave turning the correct way and give a way more accurate appearance.
3. Detail. The quality ropes give a way more defined finish especially with served lines and seizing etc.
4. Fluffing. Very little
5. Usability. It makes rigging so much easier using quality rope. This sounds weird however everything just works better. (Well for me anyway)
6. Your finished model is visually improved with the aftermarket ropes. In my case I need all the help I can get and this goes a long way.
Apologies for the long post but this is a subject close to my heart at present. I used Drydock models rope (cotton) on my Xebec (was so cool) and currently I am attempting to rig my Bounty with left over kit ropes and the fun index is noticeable. Visually the difference is off the charts.
The downside- the aftermarket ropes are expensive- especially for me getting these to SA with duties and courier costs.
Lastly have a look at Peters (
@Ptèr ) Xebe Grant