Not to neglect the starboard side, I was also carving reverse image carvings of the CR and HM carvings for that area.
The two reverse image carvings side by side.
The first CR carving in place on the starboard gallery.
The starboard side HM carving in progress.
It was right about then that friend and modeller Greg Herbert contacted me and made me aware of a booklet that he had come across called Ship Models which was essentially a guide to the ship model exhibition in the Museum of Fine Arts Boston. In that booklet was a photo of a painting of the Soveraigne, England 1737, painting on vellum by Peter Pett; ca, 1637 signed by Sir Phineas Pett, and built by his son, Peter, at Woolich in 1637.
The sculptures shown on this depiction of The Sovereign were entirely different than the Payne engraving and the Van de Velde sketch. A dilemma indeed. After consulting with Lars Bruzelius at the University of Upsala, he noted that there was a reference in States Papers where indeed, Peter Pett had presented a painting to King Charles I for approval and Charles had asked for changes to the ornamentation on the gallery area, those changes which are reflected in the Payne and Van de Velde drawings.
*************************************************************
States Papers Domestic Vol. 350, No 70 [PRO]
"Alsoe the three figures in the upper strakes to be altered into a badge of Carved worke answerable to the other strake that runneth faire with it, and to be guilt answerable to the rest."
*************************************************************
It can then perhaps be said that this representation of the Starboard side was "as presented" to Charles I for approval by Peter Pett, and the Payne engraving and the Van de Velde sketch were "as built".
Now I had a big decision to make as I was tempted to change the starboard side and follow the painting on vellum attributed to Peter Pett.
The Peter Pett painting at the Museum of Fine Arts Boston.
The gallery section up close showing remarkably different Cupolas.
More to follow.........
Bill