French war-ship Saint-Philippe 1693 - scale 1/72 - from Lemineur monograph

Hello boys,

I found this view of the St Philippe 1690 into WzM book, I've noticed in red color :

Avant.jpg

I have now two variants :

1 - The third down hance stopped forwards the hawse-holes (into Lemineur"s monograph,
the three rails are in the same plan, disposition almost inesthetic and probably wrong

Can B.jpg

2 - I place the hawse-holes like I did with the HMS Prince :

Volet 5.jpg

What do you think about ?

Following works of this morning :

Bordage T.jpg

Bordage U.jpg
 
Hi CRI-CRI!

Below are three foreship drawings by contemporary draftsmen.

SANY1253.JPG
"Le Brillant".

SANY1256.JPG
"Saint Louis". Drawing by Jean Bérain (1640-1711).

SANY1258.JPG
"Mythologie". Drawing by Jean Bérain.

In all drawings the hawseholes are free for the outgoing anchor cable. On the other hand, I am also convinced that Mr. Lemineur used contemporary records for his monograph and his drawings are correct. It is a personal decision to make construction changes when there are no serious, obvious errors.

Rebuilding a model as elaborate as the Saint-Philippe is a formidable challenge and requires many decisions by the builder. What you have achieved so far is beautiful and I enjoy following your research and progress. An exciting ship!

Best regards
Thomas
 
Back
Top