My vote is to stretch your budget for the Caldercraft kit…
-
LUCZORAMA SHIPWRECK SCAVENGER HUNT GIVEAWAY. 4 Weeks of Fun • 1 Legendary Prize ((OcCre’s Fram Ship)) • Global Crew Welcome!
**VIEW THREAD HERE**
I found two topics, which are maybe helping to make a decision .....
1) Unboxing the Caldercraft Victory kit by @Hoss6262
and
2) the finished Victory built by @Ken
1) Unboxing the Caldercraft Victory kit by @Hoss6262
H.M.S. Victory - Caldercraft - Unboxing
Recently JohnB163 had some questions about people's experience with ZHL models (which are quality productions), specifically the H.M.S. Victory. I happen to have the Caldercraft version of the ship in dry dock (storage closet). If I had not gotten it as a gift, I may have picked up ZHL's...
shipsofscale.com
and
2) the finished Victory built by @Ken
HMS Victory, Caldercraft
Here is my finished model of HMS VICTORY made from a Caldercraft kit. It was made straight from the box with no enhancements or any additional material, using only the plans and manual provided. There was a lot of work involved but it was fairly straight forward and I think that any moderately...
shipsofscale.com
- Joined
- Mar 1, 2022
- Messages
- 605
- Points
- 308
That's a good point, Uwek. Indeed Panart's and sergal's versions aren't excellent in any respect ... IMHO.
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2017
- Messages
- 1,177
- Points
- 443
@Ken's (the "other" Ken) 
shows a wonderful example of the completed Caldercraft HMS Victory. I'm sure he can offer a very in-depth impression of the kit as he has completed his journey. Again, a great, accurate example of HMS Victory.
I did do an unboxing of the kit to share my impression of it for the SoS community. I did sell my Caldercraft HMS Victory to another SoS member when I decided to start scratch building. I can say, with confidence, the kit is of very high quality. All of the wood, hardware fittings, rope and brass photo etching pieces are top notch. There is no cheap casted "white metal" parts. The guns are all turned brass. The instructions and plans seem quite clear. But again, since @Ken actually built the model he would be able to provide a better impression on how well they served him.
Uwek makes a very good point, no surprise there.
This is a very comprehensive kit. It would take you a few years to complete, so the investment can be realized over that time. If I were to build any HMS Victory from a kit, it would be Caldercraft's HMS Victory and no other. I am confident you would NOT be disappointed with this kit.
I hope this helps you in your decision making process.
Cheers,
Ken
shows a wonderful example of the completed Caldercraft HMS Victory. I'm sure he can offer a very in-depth impression of the kit as he has completed his journey. Again, a great, accurate example of HMS Victory.I did do an unboxing of the kit to share my impression of it for the SoS community. I did sell my Caldercraft HMS Victory to another SoS member when I decided to start scratch building. I can say, with confidence, the kit is of very high quality. All of the wood, hardware fittings, rope and brass photo etching pieces are top notch. There is no cheap casted "white metal" parts. The guns are all turned brass. The instructions and plans seem quite clear. But again, since @Ken actually built the model he would be able to provide a better impression on how well they served him.
Uwek makes a very good point, no surprise there.
This is a very comprehensive kit. It would take you a few years to complete, so the investment can be realized over that time. If I were to build any HMS Victory from a kit, it would be Caldercraft's HMS Victory and no other. I am confident you would NOT be disappointed with this kit.I hope this helps you in your decision making process.
Cheers,
Ken
Have a look at this website where you can follow the construction of the Caldercraft Victory step-by-step.
It will give you a very good idea of how this model has been conceived and how it all fits together.
It will give you a very good idea of how this model has been conceived and how it all fits together.
JoTiKa Ltd. ~ HMS Victory Construction Page 2.
JoTiKa Ltd. manufacturer and distributor of classic scale model kits from Caldercraft, Mini Fleet, Nelsons Navy, Heritage series - including The Mary Rose - Krick, HFM Marine and many more.
jotika-ltd.com
Hallo @Roczki
we wish you all the BEST and a HAPPY BIRTHDAY
Did you finaly decide which kit you will buy?
Děkuji za přání k narozeninám. Rozhodl jsem se pro Caldercraft, ale nebude to hned. Děkuji za pomoc s výběrem.
Thank you for your birthday wishes. I've decided on Caldercraft, but it won't be right away. Thank you for your help with the selection.
Last edited by a moderator:
You are welcome
Hope to see a building log - it is a very interesting kit!
- Joined
- Jun 17, 2021
- Messages
- 2,950
- Points
- 588
As I gather from the members experienced with this and other kits of this ship, you have made a good choice. This really sounds like a case of you get what you pay for. ( Not always true in this hobby.) I hope your choice will provide you with many hours of enjoyment and satisfaction. You have your work cut out for you. But as you can gather from all the support you have experienced so far, you have a very large group on this forum with experience building this model who, I am sure, are ready and eager to help you with the process. Happy modelling! 
Pete
Pete
Neither you suggested
If possible go to shop and look.
I’m not a kit builder but read / seen
Skill level is critical as well as problem solving.
“
totally agree with Uwe,my vote goes for the Jokita/Caldercraft kit.To my knowledge,the only error on Caldercraft's kit is the lack of split/scarphed skid beams for the ships boats.These are depicted as one complete piece.This is an easy fix using spare timber in the kit.
All other kit's are full of compromises and historical inaccuracies,chances are you will end up making changes and find you could end up spending more than the higher price of Jokita's kit.
Kind Regards”
2020 here on ships of scale.
“Have a look at the shapeways fittings for your model. They look like excellent replacement parts.”
Bryian comment
If possible go to shop and look.
I’m not a kit builder but read / seen
Skill level is critical as well as problem solving.
“
totally agree with Uwe,my vote goes for the Jokita/Caldercraft kit.To my knowledge,the only error on Caldercraft's kit is the lack of split/scarphed skid beams for the ships boats.These are depicted as one complete piece.This is an easy fix using spare timber in the kit.
All other kit's are full of compromises and historical inaccuracies,chances are you will end up making changes and find you could end up spending more than the higher price of Jokita's kit.
Kind Regards”
2020 here on ships of scale.
“Have a look at the shapeways fittings for your model. They look like excellent replacement parts.”
Bryian comment
- Joined
- Mar 1, 2022
- Messages
- 605
- Points
- 308
That's a wise hint!
I don't know of any HMS Victory of the ones you mention. I can't choose any of them. But, have you contemplated Occre's? It's an idea, mainly, because I like the way the company works.
I leave you the following link: https://occre.com/products/hms-vict...MIvemZ5KbOhwMVupdoCR3YnyuNEAAYASAAEgJfpvD_BwE
Cheers
I leave you the following link: https://occre.com/products/hms-vict...MIvemZ5KbOhwMVupdoCR3YnyuNEAAYASAAEgJfpvD_BwE
Cheers
IMHO for the price it has far too many mistakes. Some of these are quite obvious such as the twisted wire decoration on the main rail at the head, incorrect cannon pattern, and gratings that are totally out of scale. There are more, but these jump out as someone's fantasy at OcCre rather than being at least a little bit more realistic. I am in communication with them now regarding these and they are quite receptive to getting this information. I have no idea what they will do with it, but they seem to be genuinely interested. An example showing the main head rail is below. The left is the OcCre design, the contemporary model is Victory 1765 and the last is Victory today which is based on her time at Trafalgar.
Allan
Hello everyone,
I tried a few days ago to order a figurehead for a 1/200 Victory from Shapeways because the one that Caldercraft provides in their kit is not even to consider. But... just heard from Ben from MidwestModelShop that Shapeways went bankrupt. Now I'm looking where to find the stuff that was offered on their site. I also tried to order several items for my Trumpeter RMS Titanic. I build both models simultaneously. I have bought almost all of the parts that Woody's offers on his site, but still looking for more parts to enhance my models. Anyway the Figurehead for the HMS Victory is the most important for now because the thin one provided from Caldercraft really looks like a peace of cr... Sorry.
Thanks for any response. Daniel
I tried a few days ago to order a figurehead for a 1/200 Victory from Shapeways because the one that Caldercraft provides in their kit is not even to consider. But... just heard from Ben from MidwestModelShop that Shapeways went bankrupt. Now I'm looking where to find the stuff that was offered on their site. I also tried to order several items for my Trumpeter RMS Titanic. I build both models simultaneously. I have bought almost all of the parts that Woody's offers on his site, but still looking for more parts to enhance my models. Anyway the Figurehead for the HMS Victory is the most important for now because the thin one provided from Caldercraft really looks like a peace of cr... Sorry.
Thanks for any response. Daniel
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2021
- Messages
- 278
- Points
- 168
Daniel, have you tried contacting the guy who created the figurehead, his website is here: https://hms-victory.net/?p=1545. Activity seems to have stopped about 5 years ago but you never know. It would certainly be a shame if that .STL is lost to the community.