Book review Book Review: "BUILDING PLANK-ON-FRAME SHIP MODELS" by Ron McCarthy

  • Thread starter Thread starter Uwek
  • Start date Start date
  • Watchers Watchers 6
and these are the drawings of the Royal Caroline launched in 1650 - McCarthy mentioned them in his book, according him, the line drawings show very much similarities

large (7).jpg
Scale 1:48. A drawing of the Royal yacht Royal Caroline (1750). Showing sheer lines with inboard detail, body plan with stern board, and longitudinal half-breadth. With the following inscriptions in pencil: -'This drawing represents the yacht built in 1749 afterwards (1761) renamed Royal Charlotte C.K.' -'Royal Caroline...in 1700 repaired in 1733 not from this draught One built in room of this in 1749 and her name altered to Royal Charlotte in 1761 Taken to pieces in 1830' -'R Caroline 1749 renamed R Charlotte 1761 broken up 1820'
Read more at http://collections.rmg.co.uk/collections/objects/459290.html#hGlFTUAeYCsh0WyH.99
 
Awesome so Basically if the plans cant be had for the exact Name "Cruiser" the Royal Caroline plans should suffice? My Aim is to try and track down Plans. I wont get to build it for some time, but I will eventually build it. My first up will be Constellation then I'll decide on This or Batavia. Gonna go look through the links provided and continue to search for plans hopefully I will find some information in the links to lead me in the right direction
 
I think the full plans from Ron McCarthy will avaialble from the publisher or AI am hoping thec can hook us up with somebody.

I dont think the Caroline plans are the same they just used the same hull design for the Cruiser as the Carolines hull was so successfull,the Cruiser was rigged as a Snow mentioned in the book.
 
Here is Conway Maritime Press website where we can ask about full size plans made by Ron McCarthy

https://openlibrary.org/publishers/Conway_Maritime_Press_Ltd

https://openlibrary.org/contact
I sent a message to them from your links. searching the web for information is like work, but I do enjoy doing it even though its full of dead ends. the detective instincts we all have kicks in and I just spend all day looking sometimes weeks. I will run some deep web search also hopefully something can be found. lots of trash and viruses in those to wade through.
 
Received this book today already 1/3 the way through the read and its great so far. I sent an email to the published for Plan info and haven't received anything from them. one of the publishers is here in Maryland and does list an address and phone number so tomorrow morning Ill be on the phone to them.
 
I have a full cross section drawing of the USS Constellation I will be trying my hand at rendering that in cad for Blueprints and submitting for a group build here. I may need some help with the process as I've never done that I use cad for drawing 3D prints but not Plans so I'm unsure of the process fully
 
Building Plank-On-Frame Ship Models
by Ron McCarthy

View attachment 40660 View attachment 40661
  • Paperback or HardCover: 192 pages
  • Publisher: Conway Maritime Press Ltd; New edition edition (25 Nov. 2004) or Naval Institute Press (1994)
  • Language: English
  • Product Dimensions: 19 x 1.3 x 24.1 cm

Synopsis:

The plank-on-frame method is the pre-eminent ship modeling technique, and this practical manual is the foremost guide to its intricacies. Taking as his example the two-masted sloopCruiser of 1752, the author leads the shipwrights through every stage of building a model of the vessel, from preliminary research and taking off lines to the actual construction of the hull, fittings, masting, and rigging. Each step is illustrated with explanatory line drawings and photographs.

Though a single ship is employed as an example, the techniques can equally well be applied to any wooden sailing ship, and for this reason the book is an essential tool for model makers - beginners and the experienced alike.

View attachment 40662 View attachment 40663


About the Author:

Ron McCarthy became a professional model maker after he left school at the age of 14. In the Second World War, he built 100-foot-to-the inch Admiralty recognition vessels and was a member of the team that built Mulberry Harbor.

View attachment 40664 View attachment 40665


Contents:

Acknowledgements, Foreword
Chapter 1 - First Considerations (page 9 to 22)
Chapter 2 - Making the Draughts (page 23 to 45)
Chapter 3 - Frame Structure (page 46 to 56)
Chapter 4 - External Planking (page 57 to 67)
Chapter 5 - Internal Structure (page 68 to 84)
Chapter 6 - Detail - Above and Below (page 85 to 106)
Chapter 7 - Masts and Spars (page 107 to 119)
Chapter 8 - The Standing Rigging (page 120 to 142)
Chapter 9 - The Running Rigging (page 143 to 178)
Chapter 10 Some Basics on Sails (page 179 to 186)
Recommended Reading


View attachment 40668 View attachment 40666

Review:
by John S.Reid from 2012 on amazon.com wich is describing the book, its content and qualities very well

Anyone considering this book is obviously experienced in, or interested in, building models of sailing ships. Those who are already experienced in building sailing ship models will likely have the necessary background to appreciate this well-written tome. It is clear and concise in describing a plank-on-frame build of a very modest scale (approx. 14 inch hull length) model of a 1752-era British frigate (the Cruiser). The author presents the build exercise in a very approachable (and not at all intimidating) manner.
However, for those who are not experienced model ship builders, this can still be a very good book, provide you have some background. To wit:
Models of sailing ships consist of essentially three different types: (i) solid hull, in which a solid block of wood is used for the hull; (ii) plank-on-bulkhead (POB), in which the hull is formed from solid wall bulkheads spaced apart along the length of the ship, and the planking is applied over the outer surface of the bulkheads (and most suppliers of wooden model kits provide this type of construction); and (iii) plank-on-frame (POF) construction, wherein the hull is formed from "U" and/or "V" shaped "frames" that are spaced apart along the length of the ship, and the planking is applied over both the outer and inner surfaces of the frames. POF construction is nearest to the "real thing". Pretty much POF construction of a ship model is for the purist, since a fully planked POF model is nearly indistinguishable in external appearance from a POB model. But if your goal is not just to build a ship model, but to replicate the original build experience (in scale), then POF building is the way to go. That said, this book is a "must read" for any ship modeler wanting to get into POF model ship building. HOWEVER: the author does assume some familiarity on the part of the reader with wooden sailing ship construction and ship terms. To that end, for the novice I highly recommend supplementing this book with the following books (as regards hull construction - rigging is a whole different subject): (i) Building the Wooden Fighting Ship (by James Moore); and (ii) A Sea Of Words (by Dean King). The former text is a description of how wooden sailing ships were actually built - an essential understanding for any model ship builder regardless of the type of model construction you wish to undertake. (And I would recommend reading this book first.) The latter text is a lexicon of ship terms you will need to know in order to appreciate Building Plank on Frame Ship Models, and indeed any model ship building exercise.
Regarding the author (Ron McCarthy), he built ship models professionally for 56 years, so he knows what he's talking about.
So, if you are an experienced model shipbuilder wanting to move from POB to POF construction, this is a great book by itself. But if you are a novice model shipbuilder wanting to gain a fuller understanding of the building of sailing ships (and models thereof), this book (while still a great read) will need to be supplemented with some additional reading in order for you to fully appreciate the book. In any event, for the dedicated builder of model sailing ships, this book is an essential tome to add to your library.


And have in mind, that half of the book McCarthy is describing techniques which can be easily used also for POB models......

There are plenty of used copies available f.e. on abebooks for arround 5 to 8 US$ to buy -> try to get one -> Recommended for the start in POF, but not for a beginner in ship modelling


View attachment 40669 View attachment 40670

View attachment 40671 View attachment 40672

View attachment 40673 View attachment 40674

View attachment 40675

more Look Inside photos you can find the next post of this topic
Hello, i was just wondering if you did a review of the book Building the Wooden Fighting Ship (by James Moore)
 
AS ALWAYS OLHA GREAT REVIEW. VICTORY THROUGH JESUES FOR THE RIGHT OF FREEDOM. FROM SCRIPTURES I WILL LEAD TO TO VICTORY. GOD BLESS STAY SAFE ALL DON
 
Building Plank-On-Frame Ship Models
by Ron McCarthy

View attachment 40660 View attachment 40661
  • Paperback or HardCover: 192 pages
  • Publisher: Conway Maritime Press Ltd; New edition edition (25 Nov. 2004) or Naval Institute Press (1994)
  • Language: English
  • Product Dimensions: 19 x 1.3 x 24.1 cm

Synopsis:

The plank-on-frame method is the pre-eminent ship modeling technique, and this practical manual is the foremost guide to its intricacies. Taking as his example the two-masted sloopCruiser of 1752, the author leads the shipwrights through every stage of building a model of the vessel, from preliminary research and taking off lines to the actual construction of the hull, fittings, masting, and rigging. Each step is illustrated with explanatory line drawings and photographs.

Though a single ship is employed as an example, the techniques can equally well be applied to any wooden sailing ship, and for this reason the book is an essential tool for model makers - beginners and the experienced alike.

View attachment 40662 View attachment 40663


About the Author:

Ron McCarthy became a professional model maker after he left school at the age of 14. In the Second World War, he built 100-foot-to-the inch Admiralty recognition vessels and was a member of the team that built Mulberry Harbor.

View attachment 40664 View attachment 40665


Contents:

Acknowledgements, Foreword
Chapter 1 - First Considerations (page 9 to 22)
Chapter 2 - Making the Draughts (page 23 to 45)
Chapter 3 - Frame Structure (page 46 to 56)
Chapter 4 - External Planking (page 57 to 67)
Chapter 5 - Internal Structure (page 68 to 84)
Chapter 6 - Detail - Above and Below (page 85 to 106)
Chapter 7 - Masts and Spars (page 107 to 119)
Chapter 8 - The Standing Rigging (page 120 to 142)
Chapter 9 - The Running Rigging (page 143 to 178)
Chapter 10 Some Basics on Sails (page 179 to 186)
Recommended Reading


View attachment 40668 View attachment 40666

Review:
by John S.Reid from 2012 on amazon.com wich is describing the book, its content and qualities very well

Anyone considering this book is obviously experienced in, or interested in, building models of sailing ships. Those who are already experienced in building sailing ship models will likely have the necessary background to appreciate this well-written tome. It is clear and concise in describing a plank-on-frame build of a very modest scale (approx. 14 inch hull length) model of a 1752-era British frigate (the Cruiser). The author presents the build exercise in a very approachable (and not at all intimidating) manner.
However, for those who are not experienced model ship builders, this can still be a very good book, provide you have some background. To wit:
Models of sailing ships consist of essentially three different types: (i) solid hull, in which a solid block of wood is used for the hull; (ii) plank-on-bulkhead (POB), in which the hull is formed from solid wall bulkheads spaced apart along the length of the ship, and the planking is applied over the outer surface of the bulkheads (and most suppliers of wooden model kits provide this type of construction); and (iii) plank-on-frame (POF) construction, wherein the hull is formed from "U" and/or "V" shaped "frames" that are spaced apart along the length of the ship, and the planking is applied over both the outer and inner surfaces of the frames. POF construction is nearest to the "real thing". Pretty much POF construction of a ship model is for the purist, since a fully planked POF model is nearly indistinguishable in external appearance from a POB model. But if your goal is not just to build a ship model, but to replicate the original build experience (in scale), then POF building is the way to go. That said, this book is a "must read" for any ship modeler wanting to get into POF model ship building. HOWEVER: the author does assume some familiarity on the part of the reader with wooden sailing ship construction and ship terms. To that end, for the novice I highly recommend supplementing this book with the following books (as regards hull construction - rigging is a whole different subject): (i) Building the Wooden Fighting Ship (by James Moore); and (ii) A Sea Of Words (by Dean King). The former text is a description of how wooden sailing ships were actually built - an essential understanding for any model ship builder regardless of the type of model construction you wish to undertake. (And I would recommend reading this book first.) The latter text is a lexicon of ship terms you will need to know in order to appreciate Building Plank on Frame Ship Models, and indeed any model ship building exercise.
Regarding the author (Ron McCarthy), he built ship models professionally for 56 years, so he knows what he's talking about.
So, if you are an experienced model shipbuilder wanting to move from POB to POF construction, this is a great book by itself. But if you are a novice model shipbuilder wanting to gain a fuller understanding of the building of sailing ships (and models thereof), this book (while still a great read) will need to be supplemented with some additional reading in order for you to fully appreciate the book. In any event, for the dedicated builder of model sailing ships, this book is an essential tome to add to your library.


And have in mind, that half of the book McCarthy is describing techniques which can be easily used also for POB models......

There are plenty of used copies available f.e. on abebooks for arround 5 to 8 US$ to buy -> try to get one -> Recommended for the start in POF, but not for a beginner in ship modelling


View attachment 40669 View attachment 40670

View attachment 40671 View attachment 40672

View attachment 40673 View attachment 40674

View attachment 40675

more Look Inside photos you can find the next post of this topic
just received my copy of this book. Looks great!
 
I found this section of the site.
And then I ordered this book.
And while searching for a copy of this one,
I stumbled on Building the Wooden Wall by Brian Lavery.
I ordered that as well.
Isn't the internet wonderful?
Do I have enough time left on Earth,
To read all the books,
And build all the models?
 
I found this section of the site.
And then I ordered this book.
And while searching for a copy of this one,
I stumbled on Building the Wooden Wall by Brian Lavery.
I ordered that as well.
Isn't the internet wonderful?
Do I have enough time left on Earth,
To read all the books,
And build all the models?
not familiar with the wooden wall book, but I also ordered the book Building the Wooden Fighting Ship (by James Moore).
 
I found this section of the site.
And then I ordered this book.
And while searching for a copy of this one,
I stumbled on Building the Wooden Wall by Brian Lavery.
I ordered that as well.
Isn't the internet wonderful?
Do I have enough time left on Earth,
To read all the books,
And build all the models?
you can never have enough books in the library - it is like with clamps in the workshop
working on the models and also to be interested in new learning something new is keeping us young ......
 
Back
Top