I never follow blindly anybody, it's not in my temperament to react like that
I 've rectified the frames (vertical and equidistant positions) redraw all fore part of ship, and adoptef a fully horizontal keel
I noticed also that the front volute was too high, and some other details...
It seems that the base of monograh is the SR, which is a three decked 1st range vessel, and not a two decked 2nd range vessel
The real plans of the S. PHilippe are unknown, it's a reconstitution, nothing else...