Hello El Capi,
I understand where you are coming from. I decided to leave them natural brass because belaying pins from this time period were normally made out of wood, brass or bronze. If this was a typical 6th rate Sloop, I would have made them out of wood as was the norm for this time period (especially to save $) but since this was a speciality built ship ordered by the King & scrutinized by the Admiralty board & no expenses were spared, one must believe brass or bronze was used to highlight the ships fittings (BLING BLING). Based on the beautiful & accurate painting by John Cleveley the Elder, the belaying pins on the lower shrouds appear to be brass or bronze possibly. There is also early Dock yard models with bronze belaying pins that were used.
I think that once all the rigging is completed,almost all of the belaying pins will be covered with rope and the belaying pins will tend to, over time, oxidize & turn more into a natural looking color.
View attachment 464957
View attachment 464958
View attachment 464961
View attachment 464962
View attachment 464963