I guess that’s a matter of personal interest. Do you want to go “bug nuts” over historical accuracy or do you want something that appeals to you?I simply love this model and build myself, but is there any concern about building what has been called a "fantasy" ship? I can't fit the 1/48 scale version, but the smaller 1/64 scale version out later this year is certainly appealing. I'm trying to decide between the MarisStella Ragusian Carrack (possibly more authentic?) or this model (possibly more fantasy than accuracy?). I'm not attacking this model, I do really love it. And I'm not sure I (and others viewing my model at home) would be able to tell the difference in accuracy. But I just love all the details and "do-dads" included with this ship model. What a decision!
That’s the great thing about this hobby. There is something for everyone.
I personally don’t build something for someone else’s gratification, but build for me. I respect others opinions and interests but what sits on my shelf is what appeals to me.
To me there is no right or wrong answer to your question. Enjoy the hobby.