Thank you. Yes, I agree, it should look great under the final layer of oil. The main thing is to nail it well. And don't forget about the bitumen. I hope the bitumen will bring the appearance closer to the museum style.
-
Win a Free Custom Engraved Brass Coin!!!
As a way to introduce our brass coins to the community, we will raffle off a free coin during the month of August. Follow link ABOVE for instructions for entering.
HMS Alert [1777] 1:48 POF by serikoff. (Two hulls: skeleton and fully rigged)
Today I switched from hull planking to preparing deck material.
Things were really bad with that! Spoiler alert: they were! ...but I think I solved it (but I'm not sure).
So, first things first. Initially, I wanted to make the deck out of two colors of pear wood. The main color is a light pear wood, like the one on the hull above the waterline, and in the locations shown in the photo below, four pear wood slats in a darker color. Here's a diagram of their positions (the diagram is still in progress).
I previously showed samples with oil and bitumen coating here: Bitum
... but I ran into a problem: all my light pear turned out to be striped and I barely had enough for the hull above the waterline, and the one I had prepared for the deck all went into the trash... This is what it looked like:
I spent months searching... and words can't describe the level of despair... when every time you order, you see something that's categorically not right for you... And it's not that I'm overly picky, but I think you can see that the pear is striped...
I waited and hoped for a long time... and recently a colleague sent me another pear sample, and it also turned out to be striped...
I even created a forum thread asking for help finding a pear, and many people tried to help. Even a kind man from Poland responded... and believe it or not, he sent me samples: pear, apple, white hornbeam, and even ebony!
His name is @-Waldemar- , and I only paid for the shipping, but he simply gave me the materials. In return, he asked me to tell him honestly about these samples, as he, too, was interested in whether anything would work for me and what I could use each sample for even if it didn't.
This is what the package looked like:
So, I'm fulfilling the request. First, I'd like to thank the kind man again for his responsiveness and say that I really enjoyed trying out all the different types of wood.
Unfortunately, these samples weren't the right color for this particular ship, but! That doesn't mean it was all in vain.
1. I'd never tried apple wood (though I wanted to) and realized it wasn't quite right for me, so this gift saved me from a potential purchase.
2. The pear turned out to be too dark for the deck, but! I use it for other parts, and I liked its dark chocolate color. So, I'm happy with this pear, although unfortunately it didn't solve the deck issue.
3. I really liked the ebony (I've never seen it in real life). But I'd already started making black hornbeam sections on the hull, and they turned out to have slightly different grain, and the black hornbeam actually looks darker. But for some tasks, ebony is very suitable and much better than other woods! I'll talk more about this later, but I'm very happy that I now have it.
4. And the most interesting thing is that I also really wanted light (white) hornbeam! I really liked the grain and color and even considered making a deck out of it... but frankly, in the "museum model" concept (which is the style I want to make this model in), white hornbeam doesn't fit the color palette... But I think you'll also appreciate these hornbeam deck samples...
By the way, in the photo: on top is apple (spotted). Below is pear (it turned out very dark, but I like the color). And two shades of white hornbeam. From the middle, the warmer color is higher, and the cooler color is lower (there were two patches in the samples).
Below I'll show how I tried to create deck samples; maybe someone will find it useful. Again, I really liked it, but unfortunately it doesn't fit the concept of my model.
I didn't really like the imitation nailing, but with real dowels it looks very nice.
Surprisingly, I liked the hornbeam dowels (on the right, darker) less...
But the ones made from birch toothpicks (they're a bit lighter) look better, in my opinion. See the photo below.
And as they say – here's the result! What I finally arrived at.
I decided (partly due to a lack of alternatives) to use the pear I originally intended to use for the deck's weight boards. Now, it will fill all the space except for the four weight boards (which I'll be making from a different pear).
Here's a spoiler of what the deck will likely look like (without visualizing the weight boards yet, more on that later). For now, I've scattered the boards randomly to test this method. In the original, each board will be matched to its proper place (as on the hull), so that the overall tone is as pure as possible, without streaks or spots.
I coated the sample with Danish oil to prevent the punching bag from darkening as much as with Tung oil.
I coated the bottom 6 boards twice with Danish oil, and you can see a slight sheen. I did this to test how both coatings would work under the bitumen.
The macro clearly shows the grain and uniformity of the wood, which is exactly what I was looking for and had been searching for for so long. Yes, I would have liked it a little lighter, but on the other hand, maybe it would be even better this way...
Now, about the layout.
The main deck (1) will be one color of pear (pictured below). The power boards (2) will be a different color. The perimeter boards (3) will be the same color as (1), but they will be made from wide blanks so they can be cut to the desired shape.
After sanding...
... I covered the entire surface with undiluted Danish oil, using a small piece of paper towel to apply a thin layer and then wiping it dry almost immediately.
Once the wood had emerged, it was possible to see which fragments would be rejected...
...due to defects, color differences, and other issues. Unfortunately, the darker blanks (which will be used for the deck planks) are only good for half their length. So I'll have to make them prefabricated, assembling the planks on the deck. That's why I cut 8 of these planks instead of 4. Here's how the pear-colored main deck plank and the deck planks will coordinate:
And then, after the oil has dried, I'll calibrate the deck planks for width (they're wider than needed here). Then I'll sort out all the defective parts and assemble all the suitable planks into one finished deck plank to see how it will look on the model. And if I'm satisfied with everything, I can breathe a sigh of relief and continue working on the hull. Meanwhile, the deck will await its fate.
I understand that this topic isn't as interesting as the finished photos of the models, but the importance of this process is invaluable. And to achieve the expected, attractive result, you need to put in the effort and check everything many times. I also don't like all these tests, samples, and experiments, and it annoys me that it takes so much time... but how can this protect me from failure? It convinces me to do more and more of the same tests, samples, and experiments.
Things were really bad with that! Spoiler alert: they were! ...but I think I solved it (but I'm not sure).
So, first things first. Initially, I wanted to make the deck out of two colors of pear wood. The main color is a light pear wood, like the one on the hull above the waterline, and in the locations shown in the photo below, four pear wood slats in a darker color. Here's a diagram of their positions (the diagram is still in progress).
I previously showed samples with oil and bitumen coating here: Bitum
... but I ran into a problem: all my light pear turned out to be striped and I barely had enough for the hull above the waterline, and the one I had prepared for the deck all went into the trash... This is what it looked like:
I spent months searching... and words can't describe the level of despair... when every time you order, you see something that's categorically not right for you... And it's not that I'm overly picky, but I think you can see that the pear is striped...
I waited and hoped for a long time... and recently a colleague sent me another pear sample, and it also turned out to be striped...
I even created a forum thread asking for help finding a pear, and many people tried to help. Even a kind man from Poland responded... and believe it or not, he sent me samples: pear, apple, white hornbeam, and even ebony!
His name is @-Waldemar- , and I only paid for the shipping, but he simply gave me the materials. In return, he asked me to tell him honestly about these samples, as he, too, was interested in whether anything would work for me and what I could use each sample for even if it didn't.
This is what the package looked like:
So, I'm fulfilling the request. First, I'd like to thank the kind man again for his responsiveness and say that I really enjoyed trying out all the different types of wood.
Unfortunately, these samples weren't the right color for this particular ship, but! That doesn't mean it was all in vain.
1. I'd never tried apple wood (though I wanted to) and realized it wasn't quite right for me, so this gift saved me from a potential purchase.
2. The pear turned out to be too dark for the deck, but! I use it for other parts, and I liked its dark chocolate color. So, I'm happy with this pear, although unfortunately it didn't solve the deck issue.
3. I really liked the ebony (I've never seen it in real life). But I'd already started making black hornbeam sections on the hull, and they turned out to have slightly different grain, and the black hornbeam actually looks darker. But for some tasks, ebony is very suitable and much better than other woods! I'll talk more about this later, but I'm very happy that I now have it.
4. And the most interesting thing is that I also really wanted light (white) hornbeam! I really liked the grain and color and even considered making a deck out of it... but frankly, in the "museum model" concept (which is the style I want to make this model in), white hornbeam doesn't fit the color palette... But I think you'll also appreciate these hornbeam deck samples...
By the way, in the photo: on top is apple (spotted). Below is pear (it turned out very dark, but I like the color). And two shades of white hornbeam. From the middle, the warmer color is higher, and the cooler color is lower (there were two patches in the samples).
Below I'll show how I tried to create deck samples; maybe someone will find it useful. Again, I really liked it, but unfortunately it doesn't fit the concept of my model.
I didn't really like the imitation nailing, but with real dowels it looks very nice.
Surprisingly, I liked the hornbeam dowels (on the right, darker) less...
But the ones made from birch toothpicks (they're a bit lighter) look better, in my opinion. See the photo below.
And as they say – here's the result! What I finally arrived at.
I decided (partly due to a lack of alternatives) to use the pear I originally intended to use for the deck's weight boards. Now, it will fill all the space except for the four weight boards (which I'll be making from a different pear).
Here's a spoiler of what the deck will likely look like (without visualizing the weight boards yet, more on that later). For now, I've scattered the boards randomly to test this method. In the original, each board will be matched to its proper place (as on the hull), so that the overall tone is as pure as possible, without streaks or spots.
I coated the sample with Danish oil to prevent the punching bag from darkening as much as with Tung oil.
I coated the bottom 6 boards twice with Danish oil, and you can see a slight sheen. I did this to test how both coatings would work under the bitumen.
The macro clearly shows the grain and uniformity of the wood, which is exactly what I was looking for and had been searching for for so long. Yes, I would have liked it a little lighter, but on the other hand, maybe it would be even better this way...
Now, about the layout.
The main deck (1) will be one color of pear (pictured below). The power boards (2) will be a different color. The perimeter boards (3) will be the same color as (1), but they will be made from wide blanks so they can be cut to the desired shape.
After sanding...
... I covered the entire surface with undiluted Danish oil, using a small piece of paper towel to apply a thin layer and then wiping it dry almost immediately.
Once the wood had emerged, it was possible to see which fragments would be rejected...
...due to defects, color differences, and other issues. Unfortunately, the darker blanks (which will be used for the deck planks) are only good for half their length. So I'll have to make them prefabricated, assembling the planks on the deck. That's why I cut 8 of these planks instead of 4. Here's how the pear-colored main deck plank and the deck planks will coordinate:
And then, after the oil has dried, I'll calibrate the deck planks for width (they're wider than needed here). Then I'll sort out all the defective parts and assemble all the suitable planks into one finished deck plank to see how it will look on the model. And if I'm satisfied with everything, I can breathe a sigh of relief and continue working on the hull. Meanwhile, the deck will await its fate.
I understand that this topic isn't as interesting as the finished photos of the models, but the importance of this process is invaluable. And to achieve the expected, attractive result, you need to put in the effort and check everything many times. I also don't like all these tests, samples, and experiments, and it annoys me that it takes so much time... but how can this protect me from failure? It convinces me to do more and more of the same tests, samples, and experiments.
Last edited:
Thank you very much for sharing some of the testing you do prior to selecting materials for your project. Even though you don't think it's as interesting as the pictures of construction, I found it interesting and your explanation valuable. 
Thank you again for sharing !
Thank you again for sharing !
- Joined
- Sep 10, 2024
- Messages
- 727
- Points
- 353
On the contrary, the depth to which you go into detail is fascinating as well as inspiring. As you have already shown, the outcome will be well worth the trouble!
I do have one question, however, and I believe it may be a translation or slang issue. What exactly do you mean by "punching bag"? In the USA it is...;
... but somehow I can't visualize that on your ship!
Thank you! I'm so glad you found this information interesting. As they say, "the devil is in the details," so it's important to work on all those little details. Today, the results of all your efforts will be revealed...Thank you very much for sharing some of the testing you do prior to selecting materials for your project. Even though you don't think it's as interesting as the pictures of construction, I found it interesting and your explanation valuable.
Thank you again for sharing !
Definitely! It's very difficult to find good non-bamboo toothpicks. Bamboo toothpicks leave a porous end that looks out of place, so it's best not to use bamboo toothpicks, which I think you already know.Toothpicks made of wood are a very scarce and unavailable commodity. European Union wants to kill off modelers. These bamboo ones are everywhere
Thank you very much. I'll continue to post my experiments. And regarding the translation... yes, sometimes there are translation difficulties, and the translator misspelled something that I can't always verify.On the contrary, the depth to which you go into detail is fascinating as well as inspiring. As you have already shown, the outcome will be well worth the trouble!
I do have one question, however, and I believe it may be a translation or slang issue. What exactly do you mean by "punching bag"? In the USA it is...;
View attachment 549035
... but somehow I can't visualize that on your ship!
Our word "pear" is spelled and pronounced the same and can refer to both the fruit (a type of wood) and a punching bag. That's why the translator translated the second version.
I'll edit it now))
A big advantage of Danish oil is that it dries very quickly and doesn't stink like tung oil or, especially, linseed oil. It's a shame that tung oil darkens wood much better, so I can't use Danish oil everywhere. So, after it dried, I selected the best boards from the prepared ones and assembled a deck from them (for now, just as a sample).
I then cut out the deck profile on paper and covered it to create a visualization of the future deck.
The boards within the section will shift slightly (front to back) and be slightly mixed to avoid a repeatable pattern when sawing. But important! The boards will not rotate (clockwise or counterclockwise). All will face exactly the same direction to avoid shimmering (this is when a single-grain board can have a different color at different angles than one rotated 180 degrees, and even a slightly different sheen, which is not what I want). Looking ahead, I temporarily rotated the dark power boards 180 degrees for ease of installation. In the last photos, the front four dark boards appear darker at a certain angle, even though they are the same section, rotated 180 degrees. I've already written about why the dark boards aren't solid; I simply didn't have a long enough section, so I had to join them.
This is what the macro looks like. Unfortunately, it's cloudy right now, so depending on the distance, the photos turn out completely different colors. But in person, the color is very beautiful.
And this is what a comparison of different pear colors looks like (two on the sides and two on the deck).
By the way, in the future at least 3-4 other pear colors will be used on this ship...
...well, that seems to be the end of the deck issue, and I'm continuing to work on the hull. All the best!
I then cut out the deck profile on paper and covered it to create a visualization of the future deck.
The boards within the section will shift slightly (front to back) and be slightly mixed to avoid a repeatable pattern when sawing. But important! The boards will not rotate (clockwise or counterclockwise). All will face exactly the same direction to avoid shimmering (this is when a single-grain board can have a different color at different angles than one rotated 180 degrees, and even a slightly different sheen, which is not what I want). Looking ahead, I temporarily rotated the dark power boards 180 degrees for ease of installation. In the last photos, the front four dark boards appear darker at a certain angle, even though they are the same section, rotated 180 degrees. I've already written about why the dark boards aren't solid; I simply didn't have a long enough section, so I had to join them.
This is what the macro looks like. Unfortunately, it's cloudy right now, so depending on the distance, the photos turn out completely different colors. But in person, the color is very beautiful.
And this is what a comparison of different pear colors looks like (two on the sides and two on the deck).
By the way, in the future at least 3-4 other pear colors will be used on this ship...
...well, that seems to be the end of the deck issue, and I'm continuing to work on the hull. All the best!
- Joined
- Sep 10, 2024
- Messages
- 727
- Points
- 353
The technical term for this is "chatoyance". In the furniture industry, we just call it "flip" and is something we have to pay close attention to when selecting veneer plates for pieces, especially table tops. Sometimes plates are alternated intentionally to enhance the appearance, as in a starburst pattern on a round table, but other times it is a distraction and we have to be careful to orient the plates correctly. This is something most modelers don't think about, so my hat is off to you!
Oh, interesting! I'll find out what that's called. Yes, you're right. Sometimes modelers deliberately rotate the boards and alternate them to achieve the maximum effect of color diversity. But sometimes this is appropriate, and sometimes it results in excessive zebra patterns.