I prefer the darker wood, somehow it lends more character to your model.
Thanxs for the input, Mates.If you are going for accuracy, I believe it was a lighter reddish brown. Of course it all depends on if Peter wants to take any liberties, or strictly adhere to what the ship had originally. Thus far he is following the history with accuracy, no liberties that I am aware of.
The light Maple strip along the side of the test sheet may give a distorted picture of how the red Beech will draw against the gray watercourse. Whether or not in combination with the light reflection from the white bulwark. That's why I modified the sheet a bit:
Shows differently and in my opinion in a positive direction.
3 different directions of light incidence shows a different image.
Inserting the planks into the beech wood is also no problem. Will be a bit tighter, because I have now glued on the papersheet.
The 'dark accents' in the wood are now clearly visible. But this is a detail of less than 10 cm. I don't see that as a problem from a distance.
Regards, Peter