Fascinating, fascinating. What great build log to follow. Your attention to detail is incredible.
I like the smaller - better, and they are not flat.And could make them a little smaller:
Thanks, Jim. Much appreciated!I like the smaller - better, and they are not flat.
You also thanks, Dean.I agree the smallest ones will look best. Great job! As I mentioned before, if you have a vice, you can flatten them a little.
We have to be creative in our solutions.Thanks, Jim. Much appreciated!
You also thanks, Dean.
They are now so small, they are hardly to handle. After bending I flattened them between a needle nose pliers to get the wobble out. But to get them there .........
Regards, Peter
That’s a good question Daniel, they were forged and may have have been slightly flat on the ends.A fascinating little detail about the Hanks. Just curious, were the Hanks in the original BN 'flat'? I know the photo etched ones you bought were but that's the nature of all photo etched parts.
Makes sense, you would want the hank longitudinal cross section to be in the same plane.That’s a good question Daniel, they were forged and may have have been slightly flat on the ends.
View attachment 359620
As shown above, they were mostly round with tapered ends that were closed. A detail that may be very difficult at scale. As that would require tapering the end of a piece so small it’s hard to hold!
But putting them in the vice would be more for ensuring they are flat, not so much to create a flat surface on the diameter. Hope that makes sense. In fact, if they are relatively flat after making them, it may not even be necessary to put them in a vice.
Thanks for your compliments, Donnie. And fine you are passing by again.Hello Peter -
I am catching up with your BN. This is surely stunning work. The details are so lifelike and real. Its like being there on it !!!!
Thanks Daniel. And about if they are flat or round ………. For myself I think they are round, but showing first the flat photo etched …….A fascinating little detail about the Hanks. Just curious, were the Hanks in the original BN 'flat'? I know the photo etched ones you bought were but that's the nature of all photo etched parts.
That’s a good question Daniel, they were forged and may have have been slightly flat on the ends.
View attachment 359620
As shown above, they were mostly round with tapered ends that were closed. A detail that may be very difficult at scale. As that would require tapering the end of a piece so small it’s hard to hold!
But putting them in the vice would be more for ensuring they are flat, not so much to create a flat surface on the diameter. Hope that makes sense. In fact, if they are relatively flat after making them, it may not even be necessary to put them in a vice.
Impressive to make these details. I searched for these classic jib hanks, not much info about them. But I see that the both eyes are close to hold the rope in between.
View attachment 359621
Maybe this is usefull for you.
Another way to try is just make the U form and then after flatten drill the holes. In that case you could make them even smaller. Just thinking of me.
And thanks for thinking with me for making the perfectly perfect hank’s. But please consider: this is scale 1:72!And finally, you could use a small diameter rope wrapped around the jig to predetermine the length of wired needed. Then cut the wire to length and taper both ends. Then wrap it around the jig pins.
I did it in scale 1:75, but it is not easy to do and my fingers are bigger then yoursAnd about flattening the end and then drill both holes …….. in scale 1:72. Yes I have drills of 0.3mm, but ……..
T.H.A.N.K.S. JohanI.N.S.A.N.E!
I don't think the kit developers of Yuan Qing ever foresaw what a gifted modeler could do to their kit.
Kudos!
I agree what you have created at scale already is a worthy part. I guess we are all thinking about if you wanted to make it exactly like the real thing. But that’s like a lot of rigging knots, etc., and sometimes scale limits us. So using what you have made is fine in my opinion. It’s all a matter of what you envision going on the ship, and what’s possible.Thanks Daniel. And about if they are flat or round ………. For myself I think they are round, but showing first the flat photo etched …….
And thanks for thinking with me for making the perfectly perfect hanks. But please consider: this is scale 1:72!
But on this scale and now +/- 2mm in outside diameter, I doubted if anyone would see that they are more of less flat of round.
About holes at the ends: the tension of the installing rope is pulling between both ends. Just a bend for not falling of the iron.
And about flattening the end and then drill both holes …….. in scale 1:72. Yes I have drills of 0.3mm, but ……..
For now I am already happy that I made them so tiny. I will sleep for all this 1 night and will see ……
Regards, Peter
A year into this POF-build in 1:72 scale I have to conclude that it's nigh impossible to get everything scaled down accurately. At a certain point it becomes increasingly difficult, moving to impossible, to manufacture, handle and assemble parts.I agree what you have created at scale already is a worthy part. I guess we are all thinking about if you wanted to make it exactly like the real thing. But that’s like a lot of rigging knots, etc., and sometimes scale limits us. So using what you have made is fine in my opinion. It’s all a matter of what you envision going on the ship, and what’s possible.